Germany's Education System


An exploration into the inner workings of Germany's school system

Source: nacel.org

Overview


Germany has one of the most successful industries and economies in the world, but how does it maintain its economic power? This website will explore the inner workings of Germany’s education system to dive deeper into its successes and shortcomings.






Structure of Germany's School System


How do Germany's Schools function?

The German educational system is an interconnected branching system, providing vocational tracks and academic tracks that can be interchanged. However, the choice of secondary school (Hauptschule, Realschule, or Gymnasium), made at 5th or 6th grade, can affect eligibility for vocational training and university education. Different states have different combinations of secondary schools, such as the Gesamtschule and Mittelschule, but the three main German secondary schools are as follows - Gymnasium - The Gymnasium is the highest level of secondary schooling in the German school system. Gymnasium students follow a more rigorous academic course load and are prepared for university studies. Gymnasium students generally take the Abitur upon completion of secondary schooling. The Abitur serves as a college entrance exam, similar to the SATs. Realschule - The Realschule offers a more extensive education that leads to a vocational or university entrance qualification. The Realschule is below Gymnasium, but schools still hold their students to high academic standards. Hauptschule - The Hauptschule follows a general education curriculum, followed by either vocational or university qualifications.

The German school system

Source: Stefan Trines, NOOSR

Motivation & Course Load


Why are Germans motivated to learn? How difficult is their course load?

Grading
German Students are not evaluated in grade 1, they are automatically moved to grade 2 after completing the required lessons. Beginning in grade 2, students receive “marks” that evaluate the level of knowledge that they have gained. Students have to repeat the lessons if they do not receive a passing grade. Germany’s schools use a 6 mark grading system as follows -
1 = very good
2 = good
3 = satisfactory
4 = adequate
5 = poor
6 = very poor
Secondary education is divided into three main schools. Students are able to attend these schools based on their level of academic achievement in the primary schools. As a result, students are motivated to earn good marks in primary school to be able to attend a good secondary school.

Students progress through the system based on grades and academic ability, as well as their chosen career paths.

Source: German-way.com

Source: kaiserslauternamerican.com

Coarse Load and Education
German Students often have more freedom than American students. Free periods in German schools are not like American schools - German students are free to do whatever they want. They do not have to carry hall passes either. Students are expected to be responsible and use their time productively. German students also have more variability in their education. Unlike most American students, German students are able to choose between different public schools that offer different courses. German schools often offer more extensive school trips. For example, an English class may offer annual overnight school trips to the UK. This allows students to expand their learning in different ways if they wish to.
German students can choose their course load and focus their studies based on the secondary school they attend. Students who attend a Gymnasium school generally have classes in German, math, computer science, physics, chemistry, biology, history, a number of foreign languages, and other subjects. Students are also able to attend schools that offer practical apprenticeships and other options. Extra curricular activities vary between schools, though many offer sports and other activities. Schools can offer activities that range from beekeeping to experimental labs.
Aid for Struggling Students
Germany has international schools that offer a primary education in different languages for students who need them. These international schools are, however, mostly private and mostly in English, making them inadequate for refugees, especially those near the high-school level.
Students with special needs, however, do not easily fit into the German education system and are often enrolled in separate secondary schools (Förderschulen or Sonderschulen) from students without special needs. This practice has been considered discriminatory by some who advocate for integration of special needs students into the regular schooling system.






Funding & Teacher Training


How are German Schools funded? How are their teachers trained?

Funding for teacher training and pay
German teachers are among the highest paid in the OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development). The starting salary for a primary teacher in Germany is $47,488, compared to an OECD average of $28,854. The top salary is approximately $61,209 compared to an OECD average of $45,100.
Germany’s schools have a high retention rate as well - fewer than 5% of German teachers leave the field within five years, compared to over 30% in the United States. Consequently, Germany’s teachers are the second oldest in the OECD; 40-50% were 50 or older in 2014.

Source: NCEE, OECD Education at a Glance 2019 (salaries) and OECD (GDP per capita)

Germany instituted a national standard for teacher training in 2004. Training is rigorous and standards are high. German teachers must have earned an abitur to be trained as a teacher. Teacher training takes between 5.5 - 6.5 years and is comprised of two stages
- Undergraduate work (3-5 years). The length of the undergraduate portion of teacher training varies based on the subject. Vocational teachers must complete one year of “practical activity related to the vocational subject area” and other teachers need to complete school placements. Coursework includes a study of at least two subjects and educational studies. 30% of this stage consists of education-specific studies and school placements, so teachers have ample time to master their subjects. Students will then take the First State Examination, which involves a thesis and a written and oral assessment of coursework; some subjects may also include an assessment of practical skills. Teachers must also write a paper that demonstrates the ability for independent scientific work.
- Preparatory Service (1-2 years). Teachers must complete a practicum and graduate-level studies in a teacher training institute to earn their master’s degree. This stage is similar to an apprenticeship. Teachers have on-the-job training; this training includes a mentorship by experienced teachers and instruction in institutions called Seminars. Teachers earn a reduced salary during this portion of their training. Once complete, they take the Second State Teaching Examination, which includes a written thesis, an oral assessment, and an evaluation of teaching skills. Most teachers pass this examination.
The German Federal Ministry of Education and Research has created an initiative called “The Quality Offensive for Teacher Training.” This initiative aims to increase the quality and attractiveness of teacher training. $546 million has been provided from 2014 to 2024 to allow higher education institutions to “develop innovative concepts in teacher training courses and improve their quality.” The initiative also aims to increase the clinical portion of training and prepare teachers to serve diverse learners.
Funding to create equal opportunities and education - the Refugee crisis.
Over one million refugees have been admitted to Germany since 2015. ⅓ of refugees in Germany between 2015 and 2016 were under the age of 18. Most refugee students take classes that focus on the German language before participating in regular classes. Germany also has programs that give adults the opportunity to participate in German classes and earn a basic German secondary school diploma, allowing them to enter vocational programs. Refugee education is complicated by teacher shortages, as well as their varied ages and academic backgrounds. Only 5 % of refugee children were not attending school in 2016, indicating that refugee children have generally been successfully integrated into the school systems. Despite this success, some students are too old for their grades, and most are enrolled in lower level schools. Migrant children are also underrepresented in university preparatory schools and upper secondary vocational schools. There is also the risk of segregated and inferior education for refugee children since many are unable to speak German.

Source: Stefan Trines, World Education Services






Applications of Course Work


How are the lessons taught in German schools used in the job market?

Vocational education in Germany is strong, as students can choose to enroll in a specific vocation in the 10th/11th grade. These vocational schools are often associated with companies in the same fields and involve a mix of theoretical and practical instruction in the field chosen, and certification states are often conducted jointly by the state and companies in that field, ensuring students learn the skills necessary for their planned career.

Students studying in a vocational class.

Source: Eric Westervelt, NPR

Citations


https://www.dw.com/en/the-german-education-system/av-41562166

https://www.studying-in-germany.org/german-education-system/

https://wenr.wes.org/2021/01/education-in-germany-2

https://www.howtogermany.com/pages/germanschools.html

https://ncee.org/center-on-international-education-benchmarking/top-performing-countries/germany-overview/germany-teacher-and-principal-quality-2/

https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/46911775.pdf

https://wenr.wes.org/2019/08/the-state-of-refugee-integration-in-germany-in-2019

https://www.german-way.com/history-and-culture/education/the-german-school-system/

https://www.npr.org/2012/04/04/149927290/the-secret-to-germanys-low-youth-unemployment

https://www.nacel.org/assets/img/prod_medium/0000002660.jpg

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcR3I0Mdcm98FXAttbG8t-BeyjAteIYMmANaZQ&usqp=CAU